CrystalCastle

[zyntromedia]

ได้ครับ ควรเพิ่ม Milestones + Labels เป็น metadata กลางของ Crystal และผูกเข้ากับ skills / teams / issues / tasks / experiments / releases / audit เพื่อให้ระบบจัดการงานได้เป็นระบบเดียวกัน ไม่ใช่สร้าง label 47 อันแล้วไม่มีใครจำได้ว่าอันไหนทำอะไร

1. เพิ่มโครงสร้างกลาง
   text
   crystal-{brand}/
   ├── .github/
   │ ├── ISSUE_TEMPLATE/
   │ ├── workflows/
   │ ├── labels.yml
   │ └── milestones.yml
   │
   ├── governance/
   │ ├── labels/
   │ │ ├── taxonomy.yml
   │ │ ├── aliases.yml
   │ │ └── rules.yml
   │ │
   │ └── milestones/
   │ ├── roadmap.yml
   │ ├── release.yml
   │ └── rules.yml
   │
   └── docs/
   └── project-management/
   ├── labels.md
   └── milestones.md

───

2. Label Taxonomy
   แนะนำให้ label มี namespace ชัดเจน
   text
   type:
   priority:
   status:
   team:
   area:
   skill:
   security:
   cost:
   release:
   experiment:

ตัวอย่าง:
text
type:feature
type:bug
type:task
type:research
type:documentation
type:experiment

priority:p0
priority:p1
priority:p2
priority:p3

status:planned
status:ready
status:in-progress
status:blocked
status:review
status:done

team:develop
team:frontend
team:backend
team:documents
team:research
team:news
team:security
team:platform
team:audit

area:api
area:frontend
area:memory
area:knowledge
area:skills
area:billing
area:observability
area:cli
area:infrastructure

───

3. Skill Labels
   เพราะ Crystal มี skill ecosystem ใหญ่ขึ้นเรื่อย ๆ ควรมี:
   text
   skill:frontend
   skill:backend
   skill:debug
   skill:research
   skill:security
   skill:documentation
   skill:testing
   skill:ai
   skill:devops

และสำหรับ skill lifecycle:
text
skill:new
skill:experimental
skill:validated
skill:production
skill:deprecated
skill:needs-update
skill:conflict

───

4. Cost Labels
   เชื่อมกับ architecture ที่เราวางไว้:
   text
   cost:free
   cost:low
   cost:medium
   cost:high
   cost:critical

cache:enabled
cache:miss
cache:hit

model:cheap
model:standard
model:premium

ใช้กับ benchmark และ billing ได้ด้วย
text
cost:optimization
cost:anomaly
budget:warning
budget:exceeded

───

5. Security Labels
   text
   security:low
   security:medium
   security:high
   security:critical

security:secret
security:privacy
security:auth
security:permission
security:data-leak
security:dependency
security:incident

โดยเฉพาะ:
text
security:secret

ควร trigger security workflow ทันที

───

6. Milestone Hierarchy
   Milestone ควรแบ่งเป็นระดับ:
   text
   M0 Foundation
   M1 Core Platform
   M2 Intelligence
   M3 Production
   M4 Scale
   M5 Autonomous

ตัวอย่าง roadmap:
text
M0 Foundation
├── Repository
├── CI/CD
├── Docker
├── PostgreSQL
├── Redis
└── CLI

M1 Core Platform
├── Auth
├── Tenant
├── API
├── Memory
├── Knowledge
└── Artifacts

M2 Intelligence
├── Skills
├── Skill Router
├── AI Router
├── Research
├── Experiments
└── Generative UI

M3 Production
├── Billing
├── Cost Control
├── Audit
├── Security
├── Observability
└── Self-Healing

M4 Scale
├── Multi-region
├── CDN
├── Advanced Cache
├── Queue
└── Horizontal Scaling

M5 Autonomous
├── Skill Discovery
├── Skill Evolution
├── Automated Evaluation
├── Self-Optimization
└── Controlled Self-Healing

───

7. Milestone Naming
   เพื่อให้จัดการง่าย ผมแนะนำ:
   text
   M0-foundation
   M1-core
   M2-intelligence
   M3-production
   M4-scale
   M5-autonomous

Release ผูกกับ version:
text
v0.1.0 → M0
v0.2.0 → M1
v0.3.0 → M2
v1.0.0 → M3
v2.0.0 → M4
v3.0.0 → M5

ไม่จำเป็นต้องยึด version นี้ตายตัว แต่ pattern ควร stable

───

8. YAML Registry
   yaml

governance/milestones/roadmap.yml

milestones:

• id: M0
  slug: foundation
  title: "Foundation"
  status: active

• id: M1
  slug: core
  title: "Core Platform"
  status: planned

• id: M2
  slug: intelligence
  title: "AI Intelligence"
  status: planned

• id: M3
  slug: production
  title: "Production Ready"
  status: planned

• id: M4
  slug: scale
  title: "Scale"
  status: planned

• id: M5
  slug: autonomous
  title: "Controlled Autonomy"
  status: planned

───

9. Label Registry
   yaml

governance/labels/taxonomy.yml

labels:

type:
- feature
- bug
- task
- research
- documentation
- experiment

priority:
- p0
- p1
- p2
- p3

status:
- planned
- ready
- in-progress
- blocked
- review
- done

team:
- develop
- frontend
- backend
- documents
- research
- news
- security
- platform
- audit

area:
- api
- frontend
- memory
- knowledge
- skills
- billing
- observability
- cli
- infrastructure

───

10. Label Rules
    เพิ่ม validation เพื่อไม่ให้ label chaos:
    yaml

governance/labels/rules.yml

rules:

required:
- type
- priority
- team
- area

mutually_exclusive:
- status
- priority

restricted:
"security:critical":
requires:
- team:security

"cost:critical":
  requires:
    - team:platform

"status:blocked":
  requires:
    - comment:reason

───

11. Issue Metadata
    ทุก Issue/Task ควรมี:
    yaml
    task:
    id: TASK-00124

milestone: M2

labels:
- type:feature
- priority:p1
- team:frontend
- area:ai
- skill:frontend
- status:in-progress

owner:
team: frontend

dependencies:
- TASK-00110

blocked_by: []

estimated_cost:
tokens: 12000
usd: 0.05

───

12. Skills ผูกกับ Milestone
    ตัวอย่าง:
    yaml
    skill:
    id: crystal-frontend-generative-ui

milestone:
introduced: M2

labels:
- skill:frontend
- skill:ai
- area:frontend

lifecycle:
status: experimental

เมื่อผ่าน benchmark:
text
skill:experimental
↓
skill:validated
↓
skill:production

───

13. Milestone + Audit
    Audit report ควรรู้ว่า activity อยู่ milestone ไหน:
    json
    {
    "event": "skill.execute",
    "milestone": "M2",
    "labels": [
    "team:frontend",
    "skill:ai"
    ]
    }

ทำให้รายงานกลายเป็น:
text
M2 Intelligence
────────────────────
Skills: 42
Executions: 18,240
Success: 98.7%
Cost: $31.20
Experiments: 12

───

14. Milestone + Benchmark
    Benchmark ที่เราวางไว้ก่อนหน้าควรเป็น gate:
    text
    Feature
    ↓
    Implementation
    ↓
    Tests
    ↓
    Benchmark
    ↓
    Security
    ↓
    Cost
    ↓
    Audit
    ↓
    Milestone Gate
    ↓
    Release

ตัวอย่าง:
yaml
milestone_gate:
M3:
tests: ">= 95%"
security: "pass"
benchmark: ">= 90"
audit: "pass"
critical_bugs: 0

───

15. CLI
    เพิ่ม commands:
    bash
    crystal milestone list
    crystal milestone show M2
    crystal milestone create
    crystal milestone progress M2
    crystal milestone close M2

crystal label list
crystal label validate
crystal label sync
crystal label create
crystal label usage

และ:
bash
crystal task list --milestone M2
crystal task list --label team:frontend
crystal audit report --milestone M2
crystal benchmark run --milestone M2

───

16. Dashboard
    text
    Crystal Roadmap
    ────────────────────────────

M0 Foundation ██████████ 100%
M1 Core ███████░░░ 70%
M2 Intelligence ████░░░░░░ 40%
M3 Production ██░░░░░░░░ 20%
M4 Scale ░░░░░░░░░░ 0%
M5 Autonomous ░░░░░░░░░░ 0%

แบ่งต่อได้:
text
Milestone
↓
Team
↓
Area
↓
Skill
↓
Task
↓
PR
↓
Test
↓
Release

Final metadata model
text
Milestone
│
┌───────┴───────┐
▼ ▼
Team Area
│ │
└───────┬───────┘
▼
Skill
│
┌──────┴──────┐
▼ ▼
Task Experiment
│ │
▼ ▼
PR Benchmark
│ │
└──────┬──────┘
▼
Audit
│
▼
Release

English: Milestones should represent roadmap/release boundaries, while labels represent searchable dimensions such as type, priority, team, area, skill, security, cost, and lifecycle. Keeping those concepts separate makes GitHub, CLI, audit reports, benchmarks, and the Skill Registry use the same metadata model.
ผมสามารถต่อเป็น labels.yml + milestones.yml + GitHub issue templates + auto-label workflow + milestone progress workflow + CLI commands + pytest validation ให้พร้อมวางใน repository ได้เลย.