Finding
CommunityMech:000072 incorrectly says all seven partners attract TYQ1: SX is the explicit exception. All seven pairings enhance biofilm, but that does not establish mutual fitness benefit. TSB supplementation and M9 filtrate tests differ: rich-medium partner supernatants do not enhance TYQ1; TYQ1 uses all seven filtrates in M9 while AS is the exception to the reverse result. Preserve real cross-feeding, strain-omission and diversity-gradient suppression evidence. Distinguish in-silico Gephi node removal from biological strain omission. Qualify recruitment-to-assay and biofilm/exchange-to-suppression mediation; strain omission does not isolate the exchange or biofilm mechanism.
Evidence And Limits
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12954386/
Whole canonical records and all five primary main-body XML texts read, including methods, results, discussions, table text and captions. No original figure-pixel, separate supplement, raw-data or analysis-code audit. Reusable-taxon ID search and local issue searches included hidden/ignored files, excluding credentials and unrelated generated/cache content in the issue search. All-state issue titles/bodies checked; not all historical PR comments.
Lifecycle
Address in batch119; close only after protected-main merge. Self-adversarial review is not independent approval.
Finding
CommunityMech:000072 incorrectly says all seven partners attract TYQ1: SX is the explicit exception. All seven pairings enhance biofilm, but that does not establish mutual fitness benefit. TSB supplementation and M9 filtrate tests differ: rich-medium partner supernatants do not enhance TYQ1; TYQ1 uses all seven filtrates in M9 while AS is the exception to the reverse result. Preserve real cross-feeding, strain-omission and diversity-gradient suppression evidence. Distinguish in-silico Gephi node removal from biological strain omission. Qualify recruitment-to-assay and biofilm/exchange-to-suppression mediation; strain omission does not isolate the exchange or biofilm mechanism.
Evidence And Limits
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12954386/
Whole canonical records and all five primary main-body XML texts read, including methods, results, discussions, table text and captions. No original figure-pixel, separate supplement, raw-data or analysis-code audit. Reusable-taxon ID search and local issue searches included hidden/ignored files, excluding credentials and unrelated generated/cache content in the issue search. All-state issue titles/bodies checked; not all historical PR comments.
Lifecycle
Address in batch119; close only after protected-main merge. Self-adversarial review is not independent approval.