Finding
CommunityMech:000078 represents a collection of RCC, not one ten-member consortium. Carbon/interval selection effects and five-stock revival are experimental; neither establishes reduced competition through NICHE_PARTITIONING. Fast/slow labels use relative abundance at 3/7-day transfers, not directly measured per-ASV growth rates. NetCoMi Pearson-correlation hubs are computational candidates, not experimentally necessary taxa or validated PGP function. The listed network hubs cannot be credited as the complete set of growth-classified ASVs. Retain the two experimentally grounded selection arrows and bounded five-stock revival, without inferring that one genus causes stability or that all enrichments revive.
Evidence And Limits
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11153752/
Whole canonical records and all five primary main-body XML texts read, including methods, results, discussions, table text and captions. No original figure-pixel, separate supplement, raw-data or analysis-code audit. Reusable-taxon ID search and local issue searches included hidden/ignored files, excluding credentials and unrelated generated/cache content in the issue search. All-state issue titles/bodies checked; not all historical PR comments.
Lifecycle
Address in batch119; close only after protected-main merge. Self-adversarial review is not independent approval.
Finding
CommunityMech:000078 represents a collection of RCC, not one ten-member consortium. Carbon/interval selection effects and five-stock revival are experimental; neither establishes reduced competition through NICHE_PARTITIONING. Fast/slow labels use relative abundance at 3/7-day transfers, not directly measured per-ASV growth rates. NetCoMi Pearson-correlation hubs are computational candidates, not experimentally necessary taxa or validated PGP function. The listed network hubs cannot be credited as the complete set of growth-classified ASVs. Retain the two experimentally grounded selection arrows and bounded five-stock revival, without inferring that one genus causes stability or that all enrichments revive.
Evidence And Limits
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11153752/
Whole canonical records and all five primary main-body XML texts read, including methods, results, discussions, table text and captions. No original figure-pixel, separate supplement, raw-data or analysis-code audit. Reusable-taxon ID search and local issue searches included hidden/ignored files, excluding credentials and unrelated generated/cache content in the issue search. All-state issue titles/bodies checked; not all historical PR comments.
Lifecycle
Address in batch119; close only after protected-main merge. Self-adversarial review is not independent approval.