Reconcile SASW01 field-yield discrepancy and treatment scope outside the graph #1952

Finding

PMID:42513902 Results and abstract report Hulunbuir yield improvement of 8.52%, but Conclusions say 8.77%. The reported raw yields imply approximately 8.52%; preserve the discrepancy and verify Table 1/source versions rather than silently changing the primary text. Non-graph summaries should identify the BCC combined coating treatment and NC comparator; field design does not include separate BC/CC arms. Audit DOMINANT abundance claims separately from equal input ratios and 16S ASV matching. Existing S1/S2 isolation-trait discussion remains open and was not resolved by this graph review.

Evidence And Scope

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13414153/

Four whole canonical records reviewed. Three complete open main bodies and all four abstracts checked; straw repairs remain abstract-bounded. No original figure-pixel, separate-supplement, raw-data or code audit. All-state issue titles/bodies and hidden/ignored local paths searched with credentials excluded; five matching prior issues and two prior review reports read. No claim to a complete historical PR-comment audit.

Lifecycle

Separate non-graph follow-up; remain open until separately verified. Source-based self-adversarial review is not independent approval.