Repository navigation
Review AM-AB graph extension against algae-only controls #1968
Description
Finding
CommunityMech:000444: AM_AB_Chlorella_MLSS_Wastewater_Consortium
The canonical record has zero interaction nodes. Full-text Methods/Results and control tables are available: a later total-N advantage must not become uniformly faster or better removal. Preserve early-N delay, phosphate detection-limit behavior in both treatments and endpoint-specific BOD comparison. Perform the skill-required single-community dry-run/provider review only with authorization and working credentials before extending topology. Batch124 documents this open gap, not a completed graph extension.
Sources
https://doi.org/10.1002/wer.70489
Scope
Six whole records and all 15 existing nodes/eight arrows inspected. Primary abstracts and relevant full-text sections checked; TCP and urease repairs are abstract-bounded. All-state issue search covered 1196 issues and hidden/ignored local paths; nine prior matching issue bodies read. This is not an audit of every historical PR comment.
Resolution
Open follow-up; documentation in batch124 does not close this work. Source-based self-adversarial review is not independent approval.
Activity
realmarcin commentedon Oct 8, 2026
Research or non-graph follow-up remains open. #1972 at f16d4d8; self-review #1972 (review). 1187 passed in 353.41s (0:05:53); postcommit docs-current passed. Six append-only histories, 61 validation outputs and twelve mutation probes recorded. No new topology or Edison provider submission in this batch; one dryrun only; prior research extensions remain incomplete. Self-review is not independent approval.