Repository navigation
Separate observations from inferred mechanisms (batch102) - #1808
realmarcin wants to merge 1 commit into
Conversation
realmarcin
left a comment
realmarcin
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Source-based self-adversarial review at exact head ca28c79; not independent approval.
-
Retain reported precursor provisioning with panel-limited participants and PARTIAL recipient attribution.; Retain ester synthesis; remove unsupported niche label and membership-only arrow.; Retain characteristic flavor production without a resource-partitioning claim.; Retain acidification; remove unsupported niche label and membership-only arrow.; Preserve the positive tested-trio outcome and distinguish metabolomic interpretation from causal exchange.
-
Retain the composition observation, remove workflow causality and preserve detection in both conditions.; Retain community-associated detection and explicitly hypothesized mediation, not categorical colonization facilitation.; Preserve 66% directional concordance with statistical and external-validity limits.
-
Retain heterogeneous predicted capacities without phylum-wide producer or niche claims.; Correct LAP terminology, scope to canonical CPR identity and distinguish prediction from product function.; Retain bounded environmental associations without causal ecological mediation.
-
Retain sequence detection and estimated rarity; distinguish technical enrichment from growth and nondetection from absence.; Retain inferred resource dependence without an unmeasured commensal fitness sign.; Scope predicted respiratory components to CPR and separate genomic/phylogenetic inference from realized function and adaptation.
-
Re-read the four complete target records and reviewed their full diffs. Every original node and direction has a ledger disposition. Retain14of20nodes/1of4directions; remove6workflow nodes and3membership/context arrows;8renames. No new node/direction/provider spend.
-
Challenge removal versus loss of evidence: vinegar keeps all5production/outcome observations and the reported precursor route; SkinCom keeps composition, community-associated detection and concordance; soil records keep positive sequence/prediction/environment findings. Removed nodes were discovery procedures, not missing biological mechanisms.
-
Vinegar: different products do not establish resource niche partitioning. Membership in the selected trio is not a causal explanation of its output. Existing ethanol direction isPARTIAL because recipient isolation is not shown in the abstract and the selected trio excludesSaccharomyces. No universal optimum, pyruvate transfer or reciprocal benefit is inferred. Prior1042-1044 fixes remain.
-
SkinCom: both compared conditions contained intended isolates, so diversity difference cannot by itself justify the removed detection arrow. The authors interpret detection as proliferation but qualify oxygen mediation; no isolated partner mechanism is claimed.66%is directional differential-abundance agreement, not replicated significance or clinical efficacy; only one human comparison was significant and the source forbids interchangeable results. No new growth/colonization/infection instructions.
-
BGC: LAP and linaridin are not interchangeable labels. Retain the actualLAPprediction, canonicalCPRscope and verifiedantiSMASH4.0provenance. Genomic potential is not measured metabolite output/antibiotic activity. Environmental abundance associations do not establish ecological mediation. Grassland claim narrowed toKSdomains; Dormibacteria canonical grounding preserved.
-
CPR: concentration enrichment is technical, rarity estimates are coverage-based, and nondetection is not absence. Genomic deficits supportHYPOTHESIZEDresource dependence without an unaffected-host sign. Respiratory components scoped only toCPR; comparative-genomic/phylogenetic inference does not prove realized respiration, timing of lateral transfer or adaptive fitness. NoCPR-DPANNpair inferred.
-
Twenty-one graph and four discussion quotations match fresh primary text and unchanged caches. Vinegar independent access limited toabstract; other source-read scopes explicitly distinguished from whole supplements/figures/raw data. Large duplicate caches were not read exhaustively. Literal snippet matching is not entailment or complete-record certification. No cache imports or validation exceptions.
-
Four guarded record writes and four append-only histories;456otherrecords/all923caches and prior history/decision files unchanged. Non-graph raw blocks/taxonomy preserved, not recertified. Participant-use set adds two soil records with identity-only copies. All census metrics unchanged; no threshold/schema/runtime/audit-rule change.
-
Eight new tests and927combined regressions pass. Four full-record schema/strict/term/reference/snippet checks and four histories validate. Network exactly equals baseline56warnings/zero structural defects. Deterministic renderer and HTML-description parser cover456pages/1382descriptions/557arrows; these are not browser screenshots. Plain just-lint passed; explicit-runtime no-incremental mypy additionally checked.
-
Repairs1803-1806 addressed locally and remain open until protected-main merge; non-graph1807 stays open. License-gate949, loader1703, DOI-cache1091 and denied/unansweredEdison scopes not certified/resolved. Self-review is not independent approval. No artificialCI, protection bypass, premature issue closure or branch deletion.
-
Corpus324reviewed/88pending/48needs_research is not completion. Postcommit docs-current and exact-head publication require separate receipts and are not preasserted here.
927 passed in 537.35s (0:08:57); eight new focused tests. Four full-record schema, strict, ontology-term, reference and snippet checks passed; four append-only histories validated.41 recorded gate outputs/digests. Plain just-lint passed; explicit-runtime no-incremental mypy additionally checked. Explicit-runtime non-incremental mypy passed. All25reviewed graph/discussion quotations match fresh primary text and existing caches; literal matching is not entailment.
Fourteen of twenty nodes and one of four existing directions remain, with eight renames. All four targets changed;456otherrecords, all923caches, taxonomy and non-graph raw blocks preserved. Corpus324reviewed/88pending/48needs_research. Network56existingwarnings/zero structural defects. Two soil records gain scoped participant identities; all connectivity census measures and thresholds unchanged.
Decisions, provenance, validation and self-adversarial review are committed under reports/causal_graph_review, with four append-only history records. Postcommit docs-current passed clean, SHA256 cc1477bdc2ef816ab5d16b629d7418c10333456467f91bafe4e7923985aa6cda. Deterministic rendering and HTML parser checks are not screenshots. Four full-record CLI and local snippet checks executed on macOS,not Linux; DOI-cache casing issue1091 remains. Literal matches do not establish entailment; per-source read and access limits are recorded. CLI Total checks counts issues,not executed checks. Loader1703 not certified.
Vinegar independent evidence is abstract-bounded. Other sources have primary main-text coverage with explicit supplementary/figure/raw-data limits. No new topology or Edison spend. Non-graph1807 stays open. This COMMENT is self-review, not independent approval. Protected-main merge remains required.
Network integrity findingsWarnings only — a member with no interaction yet, or a participant matched by ontology id rather than by name, or one on a community-level interaction that resolves to no member. Reported, but does not fail the build. The full report is attached to the workflow run as an artifact. |
ca28c79 to
7023b96
Compare
realmarcin
left a comment
realmarcin
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Exact-head self-adversarial restack review at 7023b962afd690973c0b7cb3f33f88c55668cc55.
COMMENT, not independent approval.
The batch-owned binary patch remains byte-identical:
SHA-256 7d10885afc66c9370b48df92c9bc1b7be6604fe41649ef1bcce500972296519a.
Tree f3af21bdbe36924ccaa975032326c70d851131c2 matches the independently computed clean merge.
Compared with historical tree 31e5b3672f75e99f377d793f247729e5909dab50, only scripts/.vendored_canon_ref
changes, incorporating main PR #1834's pin 849f336e025510316a5f235eb0af8547b8bd50cc.
All curated records, source caches, review outputs, histories, regression tests, and rendered
pages remain unchanged. No new primary-source review or local scientific-test rerun is claimed.
This PR is now part of native stack #1973, rooted at #1363 on main. No protected merge
has occurred. Fresh eligible PR/merge-group CI remains mandatory. No rule bypass, fabricated
status, merge into a topic parent, or premature branch deletion.
7023b96 to
1cd64ce
Compare
|
Superseded by the protected cumulative merge #1975 at Patch-inclusion receipt. Existing issue-closing links were transferred to #1975; unresolved research and non-graph gaps are not closed by this action. This PR is being closed as superseded, not represented as individually merged. Archival provenance tags retain source commits; cleanup removes branch refs only and preserves worktree files. |
1 participant
Scope
Closes #1803.
Closes #1804.
Closes #1805.
Closes #1806.
Non-graph #1807 remains open.
Adversarial Review
Verification And Output Records
927 passed in 537.35s (0:08:57); eight new focused tests. Four full-record schema, strict, ontology-term, reference and snippet checks passed; four append-only histories validated.41 recorded gate outputs/digests. Plain just-lint passed; explicit-runtime no-incremental mypy additionally checked. Explicit-runtime non-incremental mypy passed. All25reviewed graph/discussion quotations match fresh primary text and existing caches; literal matching is not entailment.
Fourteen of twenty nodes and one of four existing directions remain, with eight renames. All four targets changed;456otherrecords, all923caches, taxonomy and non-graph raw blocks preserved. Corpus324reviewed/88pending/48needs_research. Network56existingwarnings/zero structural defects. Two soil records gain scoped participant identities; all connectivity census measures and thresholds unchanged.
Decisions, provenance, validation and self-adversarial review are committed under reports/causal_graph_review, with four append-only history records. Postcommit docs-current passed clean, SHA256 cc1477bdc2ef816ab5d16b629d7418c10333456467f91bafe4e7923985aa6cda. Deterministic rendering and HTML parser checks are not screenshots. Four full-record CLI and local snippet checks executed on macOS,not Linux; DOI-cache casing issue1091 remains. Literal matches do not establish entailment; per-source read and access limits are recorded. CLI Total checks counts issues,not executed checks. Loader1703 not certified.
Vinegar independent evidence is abstract-bounded. Other sources have primary main-text coverage with explicit supplementary/figure/raw-data limits. No new topology or Edison spend. Non-graph1807 stays open. This COMMENT is self-review, not independent approval. Protected-main merge remains required.
Source Limits
Dependency
Draft depends on #1802. Do not merge into the topic parent. Require exact-head checks and independent approval through protected main. Move dependents before deleting parent branches.