Skip to content

Bound enrichment and host-response causal claims (batch86) - #1717

Closed
realmarcin wants to merge 1 commit into
causal-graph-review-20261005-batch85from
causal-graph-review-20261005-batch86
Closed

realmarcin wants to merge 1 commit into
causal-graph-review-20261005-batch85from
causal-graph-review-20261005-batch86

Conversation

@realmarcin

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Scope

Closes #1711.
Closes #1712.
Closes #1713.
Closes #1714.
Research #1715 and non-graph #1716 remain OPEN after repair merge.

  • Retain positive 91.97% degradation without obligatory syntrophy.; Retain proposed metabolic products/pathways with attribution and metabolomics limits.
  • Preserve positive enrichment reduction and qualify Polaromonas/MAG attribution.; Preserve controlled enrichment precipitation without invented mineral or partner details.
  • Preserve positive physiological responses and qualify their causal mediation.; Preserve recruitment association and qualify its host-benefit interpretation.; Preserve formulation-specific host growth without collapsing alternative communities.
  • Retain author-proposed complementarity with explicit mechanistic and inoculum uncertainty.; Preserve positive maximum power comparison within the tested model substrate.; Preserve reported COD endpoint while exposing primary-source arithmetic discrepancy.

Adversarial Review

  • Fresh two-root baseline preceded papers; whole four records and all18nodes11arrows reviewed. Retain10nodes5existing directions, remove8nodes6directions, add no topology. Every original node/arrow has a disposition.
  • Pleuromutilin91.97%degradation remains positive. Natural En4 diversity/enrichment is preserved as parent context rather than assigned to five selected strains. Isolation/assembly are workflow, not niche partitioning. Proposed products remain HYPOTHESIZED without obligatory syntrophy or metabolite provenance assumptions.
  • Pleuromutilin public TableS2 no-inhibition assay is not cross-feeding/stable coexistence. TableS1 distinguishes W12 from same-species W10 and bacterial/fungal pool from abstract14bacteria. No unreviewed new compatibility/pathway topology;1715remains needs_research and1716identity follow-up staysopen.
  • Vanadium public FigureS2 supplies positive controlled precipitation evidence, so reduction-to-precipitation survives at enrichment scale. Polaromonas and MAG reductase attribution remain PARTIAL, not isolate/gene necessity. No invented exact kinetics, mineral phase, reciprocal mutualism or arrA function.
  • Desulfovibrio/Desulfitobacterium sulfide and Geobacter sequential-iron nodes lack reviewed exact-system support and are removed. Only Polaromonas receives explicit community credit. Three disconnected canonical taxa are exposed, not silenced;51warnings includes three new DISCONNECTED entries, zero structural defects. Source Hunan locality and Acidithiobacillus citation mismatch remain non-graph1716.
  • Populus retains positive host physiology, root recruitment and growth plus two PARTIAL biological explanations. Three workflow arrows removed. Host evidence IN_VIVO, alternative SynCom5/7/9 formulations not one combined culture. No claim of mediator intervention or inaccessible full-text/supplement review.
  • Poultry maximum170mW/m2positive comparison survives, not every-time-point superiority. Both complementarity arrows remain HYPOTHESIZED and niche-partitioning labels are removed. SEM morphology does not establish interspecies electron transfer. OD-normalized source wording leaves total inoculum-volume ambiguity.
  • Poultry reported84.4%COD remains with explicit primary arithmetic conflict:2150to436is79.7%,2150to335is84.4%. No silent swap, exact ranking certification, native-wastewater mineralization or scale-up claim. Amended/sterilized matrix and aggregate COD limits retained; non-graph1716staysopen.
  • Source access distinguishes three abstracts without main text, one full poultry main text, read-only DOCX tables/method note, structured XLSX parsing and ten visually inspected vanadium PDF pages. No paywall bypass or claim that all annotation/metabolomics rows were manually reviewed. Public SI source URLs and original hashes preserved.
  • 456otherrecords,920othercaches and raw non-graph blocks preserved; one provenance-labeled public FigureS2 caption appended, abstract-only main-source metadata unchanged. Four append-only histories, concrete curation events and ten focused tests. Required local gates and deterministic HTML-description checks actually executed, not browser screenshots.
  • Dedup984issues and65ignored/hidden local matches with declared exclusions;1680read, comments/PRs not exhaustive. One scoped Edison dry run11100characters, no paid job. Repair1711-1714close after protected-main merge;1715/1716remainOPEN. Exact-head self-comment is not independent approval; corpus and loader1703remain unfinished.

Verification And Output Records

776 passed in 260.37s (0:04:20); ten new focused tests. Four schema/strict/term/reference/snippet/history gates passed. Four full-record reference validators exit0. CLI Total checks counts issues, not executed checks. Eleven graph and eight discussion quotations independently match primary sources and cache text; matching is not scientific entailment. Vanadium FigureS2 is a separately labeled public supplement, not main-text access. Other source limits remain explicit.

All18originalnodes11arrows reviewed;10nodes5qualified directions retained,8nodes6directions removed,no new topology. Preserve positive degradation, controlled precipitation, host responses and MFC power. COD source discrepancy explicit. Three newly exposed DISCONNECTED taxa produce51warning entries; zero structural defects. Metadata #1716 remains open, not false community credit.

456otherrecords,920othercaches and raw non-graph blocks unchanged. One provenance-labeled public Supplement FigureS2 caption appended; main source remains abstract-only. Deterministic rendering and exact HTML-description parser checks, not browser screenshots. Full both-root snippet audit informational, not clean-corpus certification. Separate generated-model loading defect #1703 unresolved.

Postcommit check-docs-current passed clean, SHA256 41a63fd283f77bd90f2914af88541c9e513b4ab04979817407b78a7c46d7347c. Decision ledger,42actual check outputs/digests and self-adversarial review committed in reports/causal_graph_review for batch86. Corpus264reviewed/148pending/48needs_research. One11100character Edison dry run, no paid submissions; scoped request unanswered. Not independent approval or corpus completion.

Source Limits

  • Fresh before-paper baseline includes both roots:460records921caches,1433nodes592arrows,48warning entries and zero structural defects. All18originalnodes11arrows reviewed;10nodes5arrows remain without new topology.
  • Preserve positive91.97%pleuromutilin degradation and proposed products. En4 parent findings retained as context; workflow and unsupported syntrophy removed. Compatibility/pathway expansion1715remains needs_research.
  • Public vanadium FigureS2 supports reduction-to-precipitation at enrichment scale. Only Polaromonas explicitly credited; genomic attribution is partial, other partner claims removed. Newly exposed disconnected canonical taxa are a metadata gap1716, not silently credited by community scope.
  • Populus physiological and recruitment explanations retain two PARTIAL biological arrows, with IN_VIVO host evidence and alternative formulations distinguished. Full mediator methods unavailable.
  • Poultry retains two HYPOTHESIZED complementarity arrows and positive maximum power, with model-matrix limits and source COD arithmetic/inoculum ambiguity exposed. Reported84.4%is not silently corrected or certified.
  • One cache gains a clearly labeled public Supplement FigureS2 excerpt with source/PDF hash; main-article abstract-only status remains accurate. Other920caches,456otherrecords and raw non-graph blocks preserved. No taxonomy or auditor-rule changes.
  • Four primary abstracts inspected; poultry main text read. Source access scopes distinguish abstracts, main text, extracted tables and visual PDF pages. No full-text claim for paywalled sources; no access bypass.
  • Dedup984all-state issue titles/bodies and65ignored/hidden local matches with explicit .git/docs/site/references_cache exclusions. Related1680read; comments/PRs not exhaustive.
  • One-community Edison causal dry run11100characters; scoped paid question unanswered, zero provider jobs/credits. Earlier pending/denied scopes unchanged. Repair1711-1714close only after protected-main merge;1715/1716remainOPEN.
  • Validation and rendering are separate actual gates, not preasserted. Self-adversarial review is not independent approval, whole-record certification or corpus completion. Generated-model loading defect1703remains unresolved.
  • Final diff check caught trailing whitespace in the original supplemental caption extraction. Cache appendix was shortened to a four-word fragment plus paraphrased context and explicit archive/download/license links. Graph records/history unchanged; affected checks and broad regressions rerun, with original outputs retained as superseded.

Dependency

Draft depends on #1710. Do not merge into the topic parent. Require exact-head CI and protected-main queue after parent merge. Move dependents before deleting parent branches.

@realmarcin realmarcin left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Source-based self-adversarial review at exact head 00d6309; not independent approval. Repairs1711-1714addressed;1715/1716remain unfinished.

  • Retain positive 91.97% degradation without obligatory syntrophy.; Retain proposed metabolic products/pathways with attribution and metabolomics limits.

  • Preserve positive enrichment reduction and qualify Polaromonas/MAG attribution.; Preserve controlled enrichment precipitation without invented mineral or partner details.

  • Preserve positive physiological responses and qualify their causal mediation.; Preserve recruitment association and qualify its host-benefit interpretation.; Preserve formulation-specific host growth without collapsing alternative communities.

  • Retain author-proposed complementarity with explicit mechanistic and inoculum uncertainty.; Preserve positive maximum power comparison within the tested model substrate.; Preserve reported COD endpoint while exposing primary-source arithmetic discrepancy.

  • Fresh two-root baseline preceded papers; whole four records and all18nodes11arrows reviewed. Retain10nodes5existing directions, remove8nodes6directions, add no topology. Every original node/arrow has a disposition.

  • Pleuromutilin91.97%degradation remains positive. Natural En4 diversity/enrichment is preserved as parent context rather than assigned to five selected strains. Isolation/assembly are workflow, not niche partitioning. Proposed products remain HYPOTHESIZED without obligatory syntrophy or metabolite provenance assumptions.

  • Pleuromutilin public TableS2 no-inhibition assay is not cross-feeding/stable coexistence. TableS1 distinguishes W12 from same-species W10 and bacterial/fungal pool from abstract14bacteria. No unreviewed new compatibility/pathway topology;1715remains needs_research and1716identity follow-up staysopen.

  • Vanadium public FigureS2 supplies positive controlled precipitation evidence, so reduction-to-precipitation survives at enrichment scale. Polaromonas and MAG reductase attribution remain PARTIAL, not isolate/gene necessity. No invented exact kinetics, mineral phase, reciprocal mutualism or arrA function.

  • Desulfovibrio/Desulfitobacterium sulfide and Geobacter sequential-iron nodes lack reviewed exact-system support and are removed. Only Polaromonas receives explicit community credit. Three disconnected canonical taxa are exposed, not silenced;51warnings includes three new DISCONNECTED entries, zero structural defects. Source Hunan locality and Acidithiobacillus citation mismatch remain non-graph1716.

  • Populus retains positive host physiology, root recruitment and growth plus two PARTIAL biological explanations. Three workflow arrows removed. Host evidence IN_VIVO, alternative SynCom5/7/9 formulations not one combined culture. No claim of mediator intervention or inaccessible full-text/supplement review.

  • Poultry maximum170mW/m2positive comparison survives, not every-time-point superiority. Both complementarity arrows remain HYPOTHESIZED and niche-partitioning labels are removed. SEM morphology does not establish interspecies electron transfer. OD-normalized source wording leaves total inoculum-volume ambiguity.

  • Poultry reported84.4%COD remains with explicit primary arithmetic conflict:2150to436is79.7%,2150to335is84.4%. No silent swap, exact ranking certification, native-wastewater mineralization or scale-up claim. Amended/sterilized matrix and aggregate COD limits retained; non-graph1716staysopen.

  • Source access distinguishes three abstracts without main text, one full poultry main text, read-only DOCX tables/method note, structured XLSX parsing and ten visually inspected vanadium PDF pages. No paywall bypass or claim that all annotation/metabolomics rows were manually reviewed. Public SI source URLs and original hashes preserved.

  • 456otherrecords,920othercaches and raw non-graph blocks preserved; one provenance-labeled public FigureS2 caption appended, abstract-only main-source metadata unchanged. Four append-only histories, concrete curation events and ten focused tests. Required local gates and deterministic HTML-description checks actually executed, not browser screenshots.

  • Dedup984issues and65ignored/hidden local matches with declared exclusions;1680read, comments/PRs not exhaustive. One scoped Edison dry run11100characters, no paid job. Repair1711-1714close after protected-main merge;1715/1716remainOPEN. Exact-head self-comment is not independent approval; corpus and loader1703remain unfinished.

776 passed in 260.37s (0:04:20); ten new focused tests. Four schema/strict/term/reference/snippet/history gates passed. Four full-record reference validators exit0. CLI Total checks counts issues, not executed checks. Eleven graph and eight discussion quotations independently match primary sources and cache text; matching is not scientific entailment. Vanadium FigureS2 is a separately labeled public supplement, not main-text access. Other source limits remain explicit.

All18originalnodes11arrows reviewed;10nodes5qualified directions retained,8nodes6directions removed,no new topology. Preserve positive degradation, controlled precipitation, host responses and MFC power. COD source discrepancy explicit. Three newly exposed DISCONNECTED taxa produce51warning entries; zero structural defects. Metadata #1716 remains open, not false community credit.

456otherrecords,920othercaches and raw non-graph blocks unchanged. One provenance-labeled public Supplement FigureS2 caption appended; main source remains abstract-only. Deterministic rendering and exact HTML-description parser checks, not browser screenshots. Full both-root snippet audit informational, not clean-corpus certification. Separate generated-model loading defect #1703 unresolved.

Postcommit check-docs-current passed clean, SHA256 41a63fd283f77bd90f2914af88541c9e513b4ab04979817407b78a7c46d7347c. Decision ledger,42actual check outputs/digests and self-adversarial review committed in reports/causal_graph_review for batch86. Corpus264reviewed/148pending/48needs_research. One11100character Edison dry run, no paid submissions; scoped request unanswered. Not independent approval or corpus completion.

Protected-main merge pending.

@github-actions

github-actions Bot commented Oct 7, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Network integrity findings

Warnings only — a member with no interaction yet, or a participant matched by ontology id rather than by name, or one on a community-level interaction that resolves to no member. Reported, but does not fail the build.

Network Integrity Audit Report
================================================================================

0 error, 51 warning across 19 records with findings
Only error-severity findings fail the build.

Algal_Methanotroph_Biogas_Valorization_Coculture
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Leptolyngbya' has no interactions

Total: 1 issues (0 error, 1 warning)

At_RSPHERE_SynCom
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Flavobacterium sp.' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Pseudomonas sp.' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Rhodococcus sp.' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Streptomyces sp.' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Variovorax sp.' has no interactions

Total: 5 issues (0 error, 5 warning)

Australian_Lead_Zinc_Polymetallic
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Leptospirillum ferriphilum' has no interactions

Total: 2 issues (0 error, 2 warning)

Bacillus_G12_Y4_X25_Tobacco_Biocontrol_SynCom
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] UNKNOWN_TARGET: Target taxon 'tobacco' not found in taxonomy section (community-level scope)
  [warning] UNKNOWN_TARGET: Target taxon 'tobacco' not found in taxonomy section (community-level scope)

Total: 2 issues (0 error, 2 warning)

Bacillus_siamensis_vallismortis_HT_Masson_Pine_SynCom
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] UNKNOWN_TARGET: Target taxon 'Fusarium oxysporum' not found in taxonomy section (community-level scope)
  [warning] UNKNOWN_TARGET: Target taxon 'Pinus massoniana' not found in taxonomy section (community-level scope)
  [warning] UNKNOWN_TARGET: Target taxon 'Pinus massoniana' not found in taxonomy section (community-level scope)

Total: 3 issues (0 error, 3 warning)

Brocadia_Low_Nitrogen_Anammox_Consortium
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Ca. Kuenenia early-acclimation lineage' has no interactions

Total: 1 issues (0 error, 1 warning)

Dangl_SynComm_35
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Escherichia coli DH5α' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Flavobacterium species' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Microbacterium species' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Stenotrophomonas species' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Xanthomonadales members' has no interactions

Total: 5 issues (0 error, 5 warning)

Deepwater_Horizon_Deep_Sea_Oil_Plume_Succession
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Methylophaga' has no interactions

Total: 1 issues (0 error, 1 warning)

East_River_Floodplain_Core_Microbiome
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Acidobacteriota floodplain representatives' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Nitrospirae core floodplain members' has no interactions

Total: 2 issues (0 error, 2 warning)

GLBRC_UFMP_Fermentation_Community
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'RUG023 sp. (MAG SPH2)' has no interactions

Total: 1 issues (0 error, 1 warning)

KBase_Models_for_Zahmeeth_Original_PLOS
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Klebsiella' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Pseudomonas fluorescens' has no interactions

Total: 2 issues (0 error, 2 warning)

Lake_Washington_Methane_Oxygen_Methylotroph_Community
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Methylosarcina' has no interactions

Total: 1 issues (0 error, 1 warning)

Lotus_LjSC3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Burkholderiaceae bacterium' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Mesorhizobium sp. LjNodule210' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Mesorhizobium sp. LjNodule215' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Mesorhizobium sp. LjNodule218' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Microbacteriaceae bacterium' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Oxalobacteriaceae bacterium' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Phyllobacteriaceae bacterium' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Pseudomonadaceae bacterium' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Rhizobiaceae bacterium' has no interactions

Total: 9 issues (0 error, 9 warning)

Nitrifying_Wastewater_Ammonia_Oxidizing_Consortium
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Legionella MAGs' has no interactions

Total: 1 issues (0 error, 1 warning)

Panzhihua_Vanadium_Titanium_Tailings
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Polaromonas species' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Rhizobium pisi' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Rhizobium selenitireducens' has no interactions

Total: 3 issues (0 error, 3 warning)

Phormidium_Alkaline_Consortium
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Bacteroidota members' has no interactions

Total: 1 issues (0 error, 1 warning)

Polaromonas_Vanadium_Reduction_Community
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Desulfitobacterium species' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Desulfovibrio species' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Geobacter species' has no interactions

Total: 3 issues (0 error, 3 warning)

Sclerotinia_Sclerotia_12Strain_Biocontrol_SynCom
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] UNKNOWN_TARGET: Target taxon 'Sclerotinia sclerotiorum' not found in taxonomy section (community-level scope)
  [warning] UNKNOWN_TARGET: Target taxon 'Sclerotinia sclerotiorum' not found in taxonomy section (community-level scope)

Total: 2 issues (0 error, 2 warning)

Space_Habitat_SevenMember_Stress_Tolerance_SynCom
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Acinetobacter radioresistens 50V1' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Micrococcus luteus W4-Al-K1' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Propionibacterium cyclohexanicum TA-12T' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Pseudomonas antarctica CMS 35T' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Staphylococcus capitis K1-2-2-23' has no interactions
  [warning] DISCONNECTED: Taxon 'Streptococcus halotolerans HTS9T' has no interactions

Total: 6 issues (0 error, 6 warning)

The full report is attached to the workflow run as an artifact.

@realmarcin
realmarcin force-pushed the causal-graph-review-20261005-batch85 branch from a815f01 to dd167e8 Compare October 7, 2026 14:18
@realmarcin
realmarcin force-pushed the causal-graph-review-20261005-batch86 branch from 00d6309 to 5775ff5 Compare October 7, 2026 14:18

@realmarcin realmarcin left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Self-adversarial review refreshed at exact head 5775ff59ef6d18aada7c23267871b5ce14eb9e45
after protected main merge of #1361. This is not independent approval.

The entire tree remains identical to the preceding reviewed tree 1f4a0e3cda1ea8054239e14db2bd1df3d081df67.
The batch-owned binary patch is byte-identical
(SHA-256 35cbbb6e97e1e5d6658272a177d0eed79a5c142a971325b86c8d8f5e831ecf43); only ancestry changed.
Scientific records, caches, source-review output, histories, regression tests, and generated pages
are unchanged. Historical validation results and recorded source/access limitations therefore
remain applicable, but required CI must pass at this new head. No new source review or local test
rerun is claimed by this ancestry-only update.

The protected main queue remains mandatory. Keep dependents on their reviewed parent until that
parent is confirmed merged; move dependents before deleting merged branches.

@realmarcin
realmarcin force-pushed the causal-graph-review-20261005-batch85 branch from dd167e8 to 772494a Compare October 7, 2026 21:32
@realmarcin
realmarcin force-pushed the causal-graph-review-20261005-batch86 branch from 5775ff5 to 1357d74 Compare October 7, 2026 21:32

@realmarcin realmarcin left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Self-adversarial governance integration review at exact head 1357d744c146ae94e37306742991538b2fb5b563. This is a COMMENT, not independent approval.

Integrated already-merged main PR #1730 (fe1752572a688051e8105e5b89d3099fe2202c63). Compared with prior reviewed head 5775ff59ef6d18aada7c23267871b5ce14eb9e45, exactly two files changed: scripts/.vendored_canon_ref and tests/test_id_label_empty_adapter.py. Each resulting tree differs from its old tree by the exact binary patch from main, and each batch-owned binary patch remains byte-identical (SHA-256 35cbbb6e97e1e5d6658272a177d0eed79a5c142a971325b86c8d8f5e831ecf43). These invariants passed on all 74 published branches. Original heads are retained in local archive refs/archive/communitymech-pre-governance-20261007. No scientific record, source cache, history, decision ledger, schema, runtime code or generated page changed in this integration.

Adversarial inspection: the adapter regression still checks the empty sentinel and case-insensitive caching, now with an isolated fake oaklib module and a one-call selector assertion. No validation threshold or runtime behavior was relaxed. Fresh regressions at both stack ends: 337 passed in 214.19s (0:03:34); 917 passed in 402.58s (0:06:42). Docs-current and pinned vendored-sync passed at batches26/99. The 72 intermediate combinations were checked by tree/patch hashes, not independently retested. Historical source-review limitations and unresolved issues, including loader #1703 and cache #1091, remain applicable. This is not new paper review, independent approval, or a claim that those outstanding issues are fixed.

Digest-bound integration receipt/logs: /private/tmp/communitymech-governance-integration-20261007/receipt.json. Prior output/review records in reports/causal_graph_review/ remain unchanged. The prior lifecycle receipt is archived and will be updated only after all exact-head comments are verified.

Required CI and independent review must pass for the exact head and protected merge-queue candidate. No CI rerun, manual dispatch, fabricated status, admin merge or protection bypass. Dependents remain draft; move them before deleting a merged parent branch.

@realmarcin
realmarcin added this pull request to stack #1973 October 8, 2026 18:56
@realmarcin
realmarcin force-pushed the causal-graph-review-20261005-batch85 branch from 772494a to cbc40f1 Compare October 8, 2026 19:04
@realmarcin
realmarcin force-pushed the causal-graph-review-20261005-batch86 branch from 1357d74 to 85f35e2 Compare October 8, 2026 19:04

@realmarcin realmarcin left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Exact-head self-adversarial restack review at 85f35e204061c822bd762ea53016a705a92ef428.
COMMENT, not independent approval.

The batch-owned binary patch remains byte-identical:
SHA-256 35cbbb6e97e1e5d6658272a177d0eed79a5c142a971325b86c8d8f5e831ecf43.
Tree 01e13ea0a05371b54b55abd7a64dc4f97037065d matches the independently computed clean merge.
Compared with historical tree a4eb437d61dbc99484a5c711efd11bea5135868e, only scripts/.vendored_canon_ref
changes, incorporating main PR #1834's pin 849f336e025510316a5f235eb0af8547b8bd50cc.
All curated records, source caches, review outputs, histories, regression tests, and rendered
pages remain unchanged. No new primary-source review or local scientific-test rerun is claimed.

This PR is now part of native stack #1973, rooted at #1363 on main. No protected merge
has occurred. Fresh eligible PR/merge-group CI remains mandatory. No rule bypass, fabricated
status, merge into a topic parent, or premature branch deletion.

@realmarcin
realmarcin marked this pull request as ready for review October 8, 2026 19:11
@realmarcin
realmarcin force-pushed the causal-graph-review-20261005-batch86 branch from 85f35e2 to 923cf79 Compare October 9, 2026 08:02
@realmarcin
realmarcin removed this pull request from stack #1973 October 10, 2026 02:32
@realmarcin

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Superseded by the protected cumulative merge #1975 at 42959bef2549f9a42c3e3303a0e10fd5be99f30e. This PR's reviewed source head 923cf79cb7511f18108fd7cbc45d71856d56b2b6 was included in the cumulative branch; the final squash tree matches the reviewed integration tree exactly, and all seven required merge-group checks passed.

Patch-inclusion receipt. Existing issue-closing links were transferred to #1975; unresolved research and non-graph gaps are not closed by this action. This PR is being closed as superseded, not represented as individually merged. Archival provenance tags retain source commits; cleanup removes branch refs only and preserves worktree files.

@realmarcin realmarcin closed this Oct 10, 2026
@realmarcin
realmarcin deleted the causal-graph-review-20261005-batch86 branch October 10, 2026 02:42
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

1 participant